We were very happy with our rental. The house was very clean, in great shape, beautifully decorated, the rooms were all large enough, and located right by Cat's Cove which is a lovely spot for exploring and kayaking. All of the beaches and tours we wanted to take were all within a reasonably short distance.
The only negative was that some of the dishes, serving bowls, and pots were put away dirty. They do have a dishwasher so I just popped them in and the problem was solved. Everything else was so perfect we were just surprised at the dishes. The owners never responded to our inquiry but I called the number left as a contact and was able to rent it through Cottage Connection. mehr